ALERT: Fraudsters Milk Millions

Fraud detected text with a pixelated cursor icon.
Photo: Shutterstock

Thousands of fake college students in Minnesota collected federal financial aid, and investigators say many of them never existed at all.

Quick Take

  • The Department of Education says 1,834 “ghost students” in Minnesota received $12.5 million in federal grants and loans.
  • Minnesota State flagged more than 7,700 applications as fraudulent or suspicious during the 2024-2025 school year.
  • Minnesota State disputes the $12.5 million figure, saying it never paid the bogus applicants and removed them from its rolls.
  • Real people, including named identity theft victims, say criminals used their names to fake enrollment and take out loans.
  • Congress is pushing the No Aid for Ghost Students Act to force schools to verify identities before handing out aid.

Education Secretary Points To $12.5 Million In Losses

Education Secretary Linda McMahon sent Minnesota Governor Tim Walz a letter in December 2025 laying out the numbers. It said 1,834 “ghost students” received $12.5 million in taxpayer-funded grants and loans. McMahon’s letter said these recipients were never identity-verified, often didn’t live in the United States, or simply didn’t exist as real people.

The letter described a pattern now familiar to federal fraud investigators. Someone applies for college using a stolen or made-up identity. They get accepted, qualify for aid, and collect a check. They never show up to a single class. Minnesota State’s own system caught more than 7,700 such applications as fraudulent or potentially fraudulent across its 33 schools in one academic year alone.

Minnesota State Pushes Back On The Dollar Figure

Minnesota State disagrees with the headline number. Fox 9 reported that the system says it never actually sent money to the bogus applicants and pulled them from enrollment before harm was done. That’s a meaningful gap. The federal letter and the state’s account can’t both be fully right unless the $12.5 million represents something other than completed payments, like attempted fraud or system-wide exposure.

That gap matters for anyone trying to size up the real cost to taxpayers. Flagging an application as “potentially fraudulent” is not the same as proving a criminal collected a check. Minnesota State itself says some applications were caught and stopped before any aid went out the door, including cases at Normandale Community College.

Real Victims Caught In The Crossfire

Not every name attached to a ghost student application belongs to a criminal. Some belong to innocent people whose identities got stolen. One Minnesota woman named Brinda discovered someone used her stolen identity to enroll at a college she never attended, leaving her to untangle the mess. Normandale’s own student guidance defines a “ghost student” as a fake profile built using a real person’s stolen information.

A Minnesota State security official described the pattern bluntly: fraudulent accounts get built with stolen or made-up identities, and the real identity theft victims are often left fighting to reverse loans and clear their names. That distinction matters. Lumping genuine fraudsters together with innocent victims whose names got hijacked risks punishing the wrong people while the real criminals walk away clean.

Congress Moves To Tighten Verification Before Money Goes Out

House Republicans passed the No Aid for Ghost Students Act to close the gap fraudsters have been exploiting. The bill would stop colleges from releasing federal aid to any applicant flagged for suspected identity fraud unless that person verifies their identity in person or through live video. It’s a straightforward fix aimed squarely at the weak point: schools paying first and asking questions later.

A companion bill sits in the Senate, and the House report behind it leans on the same federal guidance already pushing colleges toward stronger identity checks starting in the summer of 2025. None of this has become law yet. Passing a bill in one chamber is a signal of concern, not proof that the underlying numbers from Minnesota are airtight or that every accused applicant acted with criminal intent.

What Still Needs To Be Nailed Down

Minnesota State already received $3 million to upgrade its identity verification system, a sign state officials treat this as a real operational threat regardless of which dollar figure is correct. What’s missing from public view is the underlying audit trail: which applications were paid, which were caught in time, and how many flagged identities turn out to be theft victims rather than willing fraudsters. Taxpayers deserve that reconciliation before anyone declares a final number.

Common sense says both things can be true at once. Fraud rings are absolutely exploiting the federal student aid system, and innocent Minnesotans are absolutely getting swept up as identity theft victims in the process. Fixing the verification gap before money goes out protects taxpayers and protects real victims at the same time. That’s the kind of commonsense accountability voters should expect from their government.

Sources:

abcnews.com, congress.gov, fox9.com, emmer.house.gov, rightedition.com, govinfo.gov