Free Speech Ambush Erupts

U.S. Constitution with Free Speech text overlay.
Photo: Shutterstock

California turned doctors’ classrooms into the government’s microphone, and Justice Clarence Thomas said that crosses the First Amendment line.

Story Snapshot

  • California ties medical license education to courses that must address implicit bias.
  • The Ninth Circuit labeled those courses “government speech,” blocking free-speech claims.
  • Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, called that compelled private speech.
  • The Supreme Court declined review, leaving the Ninth Circuit ruling in place.

What California Requires And Why It Matters

California demands that physicians complete continuing education that covers implicit bias to keep their licenses. Private instructors and private accreditors run these courses, but the state makes the subject mandatory for credit. That detail is the spark. When a government sets topics and ties them to a license, the question becomes simple and sharp: is this the government talking, or is the state making private people say things they may dispute?

The state says instructors do not need to endorse any theory. They can say they disagree. They can even tell students they are covering it only because the state requires it. That sounds flexible. Yet the mandate still forces time, attention, and framing. You must say it, even if you say you do not believe it. That is exactly the sort of pressure the Free Speech Clause normally resists when aimed at private speakers.

How The Ninth Circuit Sheltered The Rule

The United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit treated these continuing education courses as government speech. The court leaned on the state’s long history of regulating medicine, its control over qualifying content, and rules for course delivery. Once labeled government speech, the First Amendment’s usual protections against compelled speech drop away. The district court dismissed the case on that basis, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed.

The government-speech label decides almost everything. If the state is just speaking for itself, it can pick messages and stick to them. But that label is supposed to be narrow. It should not cover every private course the state touches. Treating private classrooms as state-owned megaphones sets a wide path for future mandates, on any hot policy topic that regulators prefer.

Thomas And Alito’s Warning Shot

Justice Clarence Thomas argued that California is not delivering its own message here. Private teachers are. The state is telling them what to cover, not speaking itself. He wrote that a state “cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny.” He also flagged that the rule pressures instructors to present implicit bias as a cause of health disparities, which is a live policy debate. Justice Samuel Alito joined that view, signaling real concern on the Court’s right flank.

As a matter of common sense and conservative principle, Thomas has the stronger grip on the facts. A private person with a license should not become a ventriloquist’s dummy when teaching a class for credit. The government can speak all it wants through its own channels. It can run its own courses. But when it orders private people to carry its viewpoint, alarms should ring. That is how free speech loses ground slowly, by license conditions and soft gloves that still push.

What The Supreme Court Did—And Did Not—Do

The Supreme Court declined to hear the case. That keeps the Ninth Circuit’s approach on the books in the West. It does not bless the logic nationwide or decide the merits. It only means there were not four votes to review now. California defended the rulings as consistent with precedent and warned that review could harm health protections. That argument will echo in future cases. The fight over where government speech ends and compelled private speech begins is far from over.

The Stakes For Doctors, Teachers, And Everyone Else

Licensing boards hold real power. A credit rule can sway what gets said in every classroom that serves a licensed trade. If courts let regulators call that “government speech,” expect the list of required topics to grow. Today it is implicit bias. Tomorrow it could be energy policy, firearm policy, or anything else with a political edge. Free people do not need the state’s permission to teach a class without a script. They need space to argue, doubt, and test claims—out loud.

What A Better Line Would Look Like

Courts should draw a bright line. If the government speaks in its own programs, it is free to choose content. If private speakers teach private courses—even inside a licensing system—the First Amendment applies. The state may require competence in medicine, law, or safety, but it should not force private instructors to present a contested idea as a favored truth. That line respects expertise, keeps regulators in their lane, and protects the open exchange that makes professional learning real.

Sources:

foxnews.com, usatoday.com, news.bloomberglaw.com